Many readers of this site have likely heard about the recent FTC prosecution/settlement with Amway. The action and the FTC rhetoric might seem significant. Amway is the oldest and largest US-based MLM in the world. 47 years ago, the FTC declared Amway “not a pyramid scheme” but a legal and legitimate direct selling enterprise. That ruling is the foundation for all MLMs to claim to be “legal.” Now, the FTC says Amway is “unfair and deceptive.” The FTC calls the Amway prosecution “historic.”
In fact, there is no reason to expect this FTC action will make any difference at all, not to Amway, not to millions of victimized consumers in the USA and worldwide, and not to MLM’s global rampage of pyramid fraud.
Nickels and Dimes
The FTC says the “monetary relief” of $225 million that Amway has agreed to pay is the largest in FTC history against an MLM. Even this is not true. Factoring a decade of inflation, Herbalife, which is a fraction the size of Amway, paid more — 10 years ago.
The “relief” may be historic to the FTC but to the public it is profoundly insulting. Best estimates of Amway’s USA revenue are between $800 million and one-billion. $225 million therefore is just a quarter of what Amway rakes in—in just one year—just from USA recruits. The “settlement” terms only apply to USA operations. USA is only 12% of Amway revenues. The “relief” is just 3% of Amway’s global revenue for just one year.
With the official blessing of the FTC, Amway has been using these deceptive and harmful tactics for more than 40 years. In just the last 10 years, Amway grabbed an estimated $10 billion from USA recruits! Yes, billion with a B. Globally, Amway’s revenue, which the FTC acknowledges is gained unfairly and deceptively, dwarfs the scam of Bernard Madoff, who died while imprisoned for his Ponzi scheme.
Using publicly disclosed Herbalife data as a guide, gross profits for MLMs are nearly 80% of revenue. The largest single “expense”, much larger than the cost to source or make products, is payments to recruiters — about 35% of revenue. So, Amway’s payment of 3% of revenue, for just one year, is financially meaningless and will have no effect on recruiting.
For consumers, the “relief” is similarly irrelevant. Using recent Amway figures of 300,000 recruits in the USA and a (conservative) estimate of annual “churn” rate of 50%, as many as 2 million American households were churned through Amway’s deceptive recruiting system in the last 10 years. The $225 million therefore would mean a little more than a 100 bucks in “relief” per victim just for one decade. Over a longer time, and factoring inflation, the figure becomes nickels and dimes.
Of course, purchases of Amway’s unsellable and overpriced products—the minimum price to join the “opportunity”— are only a fraction of what Amway recruits are deceptively induced to spend. Add expenditures for travel, hotel, seminars, literature. Factor also other lost income, deferred education, new debt, and social disruption. Whatever they spend—some spend tens of thousands, leading to bankruptcy and personal ruin— effectively none of the millions of recruits ever gain any profit.
Un-enforcement
Beyond the absurd “relief” payment, the settlement includes “enforcement” terms on Amway business operations similar to what were imposed on Herbalife in 2016. Those terms for Herbalife are no longer monitored by the FTC, but there is no evidence the terms were ever meaningfully enforced. The FTC had no means to effectively monitor or enforce the terms. Monitoring of “compliance“ was kept secret.
Obvious evidence that the “terms” imposed on Herbalife had no effect is that it made no impact on “sales” (in MLM, “sales” are what are extracted from recruits with false income promises). In 2015, a year before the FTC “settlement”, Herbalife pulled $860 million out of USA recruits. 10 years later, 2025, after years of FTC’s “enforcement,” Herbalife grabbed over a billion from USA recruits. The percent of Herbalife’s global business in the USA (enforcement only applied in the USA) remained constant.
Most significantly, the percent of revenue Herbalife paid to recruiters, which is siphoned straight to the top of the pyramid and is the pyramid’s fuel, increased from 28% (before “enforcement) to current 35.4% (post enforcement).
What Dare Not Be Spoken
The greatest evidence that the 2026 Amway “prosecution” is a sham, like the 2016 Herbalife case, is not what is in the settlement terms or even the shameful “relief” amount, but in what is absent — all mention of “pyramid scheme.” The term is nowhere to be found in the FTC/Amway complaint. This is deja vu of the 2016 Herbalife case, where “pyramid” also did not appear in any FTC documents, despite years of “pyramid scheme” accusations against Herbalife on Wall Street and discussion in the media. Pressured to address the pyramid scheme question after the “settlement,” the FTC chairperson told the public, “[Herbalife was] not determined not to have been a pyramid.” Say what?
It is the “endless chain” structure—unique and defining to MLM—that enables MLM to promise utopia. It is the promise of utopia, along with claims to hold secret knowledge of how to reach utopia that enable MLMs to exert cult mind-control, take over a victim’s whole life, and loot their life savings. The promise of income based primarily on the enrollment of future participants, with funds continuously flowing from the last to first was fully understood by law enforcement to be an inherent fraud. This all changed in 1979 when FTC Commissioners voted to allow Amway to use “endless chain” recruiting rewards as an “incentive”.
The so-called “Amway rules” to require retail selling, while paying rewards based on recruiting, are irrelevant. As the late Bruce Craig, former Asst. Attorney General of Wisconsin explained, “An endless chain of retailers is still an endless chain.” But, as Bruce Craig also showed, endless chain recruiting of retailers destroys the economics of retail sales. The promise of “unlimited income” from recruiting makes retailing a fool’s errand, while also saturating markets with salespeople and preventing profitable retailing. Endless chains, which base recruiting rewards on future recruits’ payments, doom the “last ones in,” and the last ones will always be the vast majority. The endless chain, aka pyramid scheme, is a calculated financial trap, a fraud perpetrated on a massive scale.
All the “deceptions” shown to be “unfair” and requiring “relief” that the FTC documents against Amway are attributable to the pyramid scheme model. The “training” programs that promise to teach new recruits how to succeed in a pyramid recruiting scheme are fraudulent on their face, as success is impossible. With the pyramid scheme allowed to continue, the deception cited in the “settlement” will not end. The terms will not and cannot be enforced. How do you fairly and honestly promote an “income opportunity” based on a model that is designed to cause loss? The FTC charge of “deception”, while ignoring the pyramid scheme, is like charging a burglar for breaking windows, not for stealing the home’s contents.
Realties: Obvious, Unimaginable, Can’t Be Ignored, and the Darkest
For those clinging to a thread of hope that this FTC action represents significant change, there are a few more reality checks:
- There has no significant news story about this “historic” prosecution or any analysis in the mainstream media, Only a few news organizations re-published a summary of the FTC press release. It seems news organizations, which know Amway all too well, recognize the obvious. It’s not “historic”. It’s not even “news.”
- It is unimaginable that the two current FTC Commissioners—one nominated by Donald Trump and the other named as Chairman by Trump, after two Democratic members were “fired” by Trump—would actually harm Amway. Amway is one of Trump’s major campaign donors and supporters. Amway’s owners are top officials in the Republican Party and the US Chamber of Commerce. The daughter of one Amway founder is the chair of the Board of Trustees of the Heritage Foundation, the main source of Trump’s policy playbook, “Project 2025.”
- The two realities above lead to one more that cannot be ignored. An eviscerated, corrupted and captured regulatory agency must still do something to justify its existence and funding. The traditional strategy is to engage in parody, theater and ceremony. This explains the FTC’s Amway prosecution that ignores the pyramid scheme, gently slaps Amway’s wrist with a “relief” payment, and then bombastically declares it is making regulatory history. The prosecution is for the sake of the FTC, not the public. Amway knows the routine and plays along, while melodramatically protesting.
- Finally, the darkest of realities. The pretense of law enforcement not only gives cover and funding justification to the captured FTC; it also gives special cover to the lawbreaker, Amway.
In 1979, shocking the FTC’s own attorneys, FTC Commissioners voted to allow Amway to operate a pyramid recruiting scheme, known generically as an “endless chain.” For decades afterward, Amway’s most powerful defense was that it complied with the 1979 FTC ruling.
But reality continued to rear its head. Consumer charges of fraud and cultism never stopped. Exposés were aired on CBS 60 Minutes and NBC Dateline. Tell-all books by victims were published. Satirical films were produced. Prosecutions for deception, fraud, money laundering, and tax evasion were filed in the state of Wisconsin, in Canada, France, England and India. Numerous individual and class action cases have been filed by consumers in the USA. At one point, Amway even changed its name to evade growing consumer awareness of “Scamway.”
Now, the 2026 FTC “settlement” provides Amway a new and improved shield. It can claim to be operating under strict new “terms” for retailing and preventing deception, all overseen by a monitoring company, which Amway is allowed to choose with the FTC.
With Amway now operating behind the veil of the new “settlement,” who can say Amway should be prosecuted? It has been, and is in “compliance”, plus it paid a “historic” amount in “relief”, (though it admitted no wrongdoing). Who can accuse it of operating a pyramid scheme? The FTC investigation, leading to a 2026 prosecution, did not cite a pyramid, which affirms the 1979 ruling. Who can complain about losses? Deception is now prevented under “settlement” terms.
Amway is under the boot of the law now. The public can rest assured it is now perfectly safe. The FTC says so. It’s “settled.”

