Pyramid Scheme Alert (PSA) provides current and historical news items that are of interest to our members and visitors. None of the reports or commentaries is intended to imply that any of the referenced companies have been charged or convicted as illegal pyramid schemes.
More About PPLS
Pre-Paid Legal's Legal Troubles
July 18, 2001
In January and February of this year, a number of stockholder class actions lawsuits were filed against Pre-Paid Legal Services, a company based in Oklahoma which sells legal "insurance" through a multi-level marketing system. The company trades on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) as PPD.
At issue is Pre-Paid's accounting practice regarding commission advances to associates. According to the Wall Street Journal of January 17, 2001:
PPD then classifies the commission payments as "assets," which it expenses over three years. However, the average customer holds a policy for only 2 years, and most sales associates never sell enough for PPD to recoup the advances. According to the company, only 26% of associates actually sold any policies in the first nine months of 2000.
Here is a partial list of class action suits filed against PPD in the early part of this year:
The complaints all revolve around the issue of securities fraud, accusing PPD of inflating stock prices by the use of inappropriate accounting methods.
The Securities and Exchange Commission launched an investigation of PPD's accounting practices. They rejected an appeal from the company, because PPD's accounting practices do not conform to generally accepted accounting principles.
Sales Associates Initiate Class Action, Charge Company with Deception, Breached Contracts, and Other Violations
Then, in June, a group of Pre-Paid Legal "Associates" filed a class action suit against the company. The suit claims that PPD breached contracts, and violated both the Consumer Protection Act and the Oklahoma Uniform Credit Code. The suit also charges the company with inflating customer retention figures in order to attract sales associates. Individuals are enticed to join as sales associates when presented with figures that lead them to believe most policies will remain on the books long enough for the associates to generate future income. The complaint alleges that most policies are cancelled before this happens, leaving the associates having to repay advances -- with interest.
Oklahoma City Attorney John Dexter is handling the lawsuit. According to Dexter:
The class includes any Pre-Paid Legal Services Associates who was active between September, 1997 and June 29, 2001. According to a spokesman for the class action, the company has represented a 76% renewal rate over three years. According to numbers that PPD released to the SEC, however, the "persistency" rate is only 28%.
Pre-Paid Legal Services apparently has no legal insurance to fall back on.
|This page last updated on